Strategies and Tips for Overcoming Automated Regression Testing Challenges
Introduction: What is Regression Testing and Why is it Important?
Regression testing is a critical part of software development that helps ensure that changes made to an application do not negatively impact its existing functionality. However, regression testing can present several challenges for developers and quality assurance teams despite its importance.
From managing test suites to identifying and fixing defects, various hurdles must be overcome to conduct effective regression testing. This blog post will explore some of the most common challenges associated with regression testing and provide practical tips and strategies for overcoming them.
Whether you are a seasoned software tester or new to the field, this post will help you navigate the complexities of regression testing and ensure that your applications are reliable and bug-free.
The Benefits of Using Automation for Regression Testing
Regression testing is a big part of the software development life cycle as it involves testing previously developed software to verify if any new changes or updates have caused unintended side effects or introduced new bugs. While necessary, regression testing can be a tedious and time-consuming task, especially when done manually. This is where automation comes in.
By using automation for regression testing, developers can save time and improve the accuracy of their testing. Automated tests can be run faster and more frequently than manual tests, allowing developers to catch any issues earlier in the development process. Automated regression tests are less prone to human error, therefore, they are more accurate and reliable.
There are several benefits of using automation for regression testing in software development. First and foremost, automation allows for faster and more frequent testing, which in turn helps catch issues earlier in the development process. This means that developers can identify and fix bugs before they become major problems, ultimately saving time and money in the long run.
Additionally, automated regression tests can be run overnight or during off-hours, which minimises disruption to the development team's workflow.
Another benefit of using automation for regression testing is that it minimises and sometimes even eliminates human error, as automated tests are consistent and repeatable, which in turn reduces the need for manual retesting.
When automating our regression tests, we also get detailed logs of test results, making it easier for developers to identify and isolate issues for debugging and keep track of recurrent errors.
Here Learn more about the Benefits of Test Automation.
Automation for Regression Testing vs Manual Regression Testing
| Criteria | Automation for Regression Testing | Manual Regression Testing |
|---|---|---|
| Execution Time | Automation for Regression Testing is much faster as the test cases are run automatically, and the results are obtained quickly. | Manual Regression Testing is slower as the tester needs to execute each test case manually, which takes a lot of time. |
| Accuracy | Automation for Regression Testing has high accuracy, as the test cases are executed by a machine, which eliminates human errors. | Manual Regression Testing accuracy can be medium, as it involves manual execution, which may result in human errors. |
| Cost | Automation for Regression Testing has high initial investment as it requires specialized tools and a skilled workforce. | Manual Regression Testing has low cost as it does not require any specialized tools or investment. |
| Maintenance | Automation for Regression Testing requires periodic maintenance to ensure that the scripts are up-to-date with the changes in the system. | Manual Regression Testing does not require maintenance as it does not use scripts, and the tester executes the test cases manually. |
| Reusability | Automation for Regression Testing has high reusability as the test cases can be run multiple times with minimal effort. | Manual Regression Testing has low reusability as the tester needs to execute each test case manually, which takes a lot of time and effort. |
| Test Coverage | Automation for Regression Testing has high test coverage as it can run multiple test cases in a short time, covering a vast range of scenarios. | Manual Regression Testing has low test coverage as the tester needs to execute each test case manually, which is time-consuming and does not cover a broad range of scenarios. |
| Human Error | Automation for Regression Testing eliminates human errors, as the test cases are executed by a machine. | Manual Regression Testing is prone to human errors, as the tester may overlook some scenarios or make mistakes during manual execution. |
| Skill level required | Automation for Regression Testing requires a high skill level to create and maintain the scripts. | Manual Regression Testing requires a medium skill level, as the tester needs to have knowledge of the application and the testing process. |
| Adaptability to changes | Automation for Regression Testing has low adaptability to changes as any changes in the application require updating the scripts. | Manual Regression Testing has high adaptability to changes as the tester can quickly adapt to changes in the application and update the test cases accordingly. |
| Initial setup time | Automation for Regression Testing requires a high setup time as the tester needs to create the test scripts and set up the automation tools. | Manual Regression Testing requires a low setup time as the tester can start executing the test cases manually without any setup. |
Common Challenges of Regression Testing and How to Overcome Them
As crucial as regression testing is for the development lifecycle, it can come with some expected challenges that developers and testers should understand.
Challenge #1: Time and Prioritising
One of the main challenges of modern software systems is their sheer size and complexity. This can make it difficult for developers to run all necessary regression tests in a reasonable amount of time. To address this challenge, we can prioritise testing based on the most critical parts of the software and use automation to speed up the process.
While it can be hard to justify the time and cost of creating and running regression tests, a testing tool with record and replay capabilities can help engineers create complex and scalable automated user interface tests in a short timescale.
These scripts, when properly configured, can be executed automatically as part of a continual integration (CI) pipeline following every new build or release.
Challenge #2: Brittle Tests
It is important to recognise that brittle tests can be a major challenge when undertaking automated regression testing. They can be exceptionally sensitive to environmental or system changes, leading to false positives and negatives. This can make it difficult to accurately identify issues and can erode developers' confidence in the tests themselves.
There are several possible causes for brittle tests, such as testing complex workflows, inadequate test design and the use of hard-coded values instead of test input variables.
To overcome this challenge, developers and testers can use techniques such as data-driven testing, which uses variables instead of hard-coded values, mock objects to simulate complex system interactions, or regularly reviewing and refactoring test cases.
This can help identify and fix any issues with the test cases, making them more robust and reliable. Ensuring that your automation code checks UI elements are present and enabled in the application before trying to interact with them or assert against them, is also crucial to reducing brittle tests.
Challenge #3: Maintenance & Complexity
The maintenance challenge is another problem that can arise with regression testing. When changes are made to the code, it is essential to modify the regression test cases to ensure that they continue to work as intended. However, keeping track of all the changes to the test cases can be difficult and time-consuming, especially as the number and complexity of test cases increase.
To address the challenges associated with regression testing, developers can utilise automation tools to increase efficiency. Automation can help to simplify the complexity of regression testing by selecting and executing only the relevant tests while also reducing maintenance challenges by automatically updating test cases whenever code changes occur.
Moreover, a test management system can be implemented to track changes and test results, which can assist developers in identifying impacted test cases and prioritising their testing efforts where they are needed the most.
Tips to Make the Most Out of Your Automated Regression Tests
Here are some best practices that developers and testers can use to improve their regression testing process:
Leverage Automation Testing: Automation testing can help reduce the time and effort required for regression testing. It ensures consistency and reduces the risk of human error.
Narrow the Focus: It is essential to focus on the most central features of the software when conducting regression testing. It is good practice to prioritise testing critical parts of the application, reducing the risk of missing critical bugs.
Test What Matters: Testing what matters most to the end-users also constitutes good practice when doing regression testing. Developers should focus on testing the functionality that the users are most likely to use rather than testing every feature of the application. By prioritising those features, developers and testers can ensure that the software meets the needs of the end users.
Transform Regressions into Tickets: Whenever a regression is detected, it is essential to transform it into a ticket or bug report. This can help track and address regression bugs in a timely manner. By keeping track of regressions, we can identify trends and patterns that can improve the testing process in the long run.
Conclusion
To summarise, automated regression tests are essential for quality assurance success. While manual testing is still necessary, automation can help reduce the amount of time and resources spent on testing while increasing the accuracy and reliability of results. Automation of your regression tests also allows teams to run parallel tests quickly and can be used for a speedier bug detection process.
To ensure the successful implementation of automated regression testing, teams should focus on best practices such as developing a comprehensive test strategy, creating detailed test cases, setting up an automated testing environment, and utilising version control to ensure efficient test case maintenance and team workflow.
